The Final Ice Cream Maker Assessment has every thing you have to know to decide on the most effective ice cream maker for YOU!
Having printed properly over 100 ice cream recipes, I get requested a LOT of questions on ice cream makers. So, right here’s my evaluate of the most effective and the worst ice cream makers in the marketplace in 2024.
Proper after, “Which machine do YOU suggest?” The most well-liked query I get is whether or not it’s attainable to make ice cream with out a machine. The reply is YES. You can also make ice cream with out a machine. Find the full directions here!
There are such a lot of completely different ice cream makers in the marketplace, it may be arduous to even know the place to start. With the data right here, you will discover the most effective ice cream maker to your wants and begin making your favourite frozen treats at dwelling.
I’ve personally examined all of those machines, basing my selections for testing on buyer critiques, and selecting the highest-rated machines in every class.
The identical homemade ice cream recipe was used for each batch examined in these machines.
From ice cream compressors to creating ice cream in a bag, I’ve obtained your frozen treats lined as a way to make the most effective buy determination to fulfill your entire ice cream cravings!
Ice Cream Maker Critiques
- Electrical Ice Cream Makers – frozen bowl, no ice required
- Electrical Ice Cream Makers – add ice and salt
- Hand Crank Ice Cream Makers – add ice and salt
- Mushy Serve Ice Cream Maker, Prompt Ice Cream Maker, Ice Cream Ball, and Ice Cream In A Bag
- Compressor Ice Cream Makers – freezer compressor unit, no ice or frozen bowl required
Greatest Ice Cream Maker Outcomes
Greatest Ice Cream Maker below $75
In order for you an ice cream maker that produces constant, high quality outcomes, and also you don’t thoughts shopping for ice and salt whenever you’re able to make ice cream, the Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker is the machine for you.
It makes 4-quarts of ice cream at a time (superior for a crowd) and the ice cream texture is constant all through your complete batch.
Nonetheless, should you don’t need to mess with ice and salt, and you’ve got a KitchenAid mixer, the KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment is the best way to go. The ice cream is clean and creamy with none of the inconsistent texture seen with different freezer bowl choices.
For those who shouldn’t have a KitchenAid, and also you need an electrical ice cream maker that doesn’t require ice or salt, the Cuisinart ICE-21 1.5-Quart is your only option.
Greatest Compressor Ice Cream Maker
The Cuisinart Compressor Ice Cream Maker is a stable high-end ice cream machine choice at below $300. In a nutshell, it churns the ice cream sooner in facet by facet testing and is a really shut match to the ice cream from the Breville Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker.
For those who’ve identified me for lengthy, you seemingly know that I usually name the Breville “my beloved” and it’s no secret that this has been my favourite kitchen equipment for over 10 years now – and it’s nonetheless going sturdy. The Breville is admittedly an indulgence buy at the next value. Whereas the Breville’s ice cream is creamier than the Cuisinart’s, it truthfully isn’t THAT a lot creamier.
My suggestion for the typical dwelling prepare dinner is for the Cuisinart. The one actual con to this machine is that it’s a contact louder than the Breville and it doesn’t have the entire bells and whistles of the opposite.
NEW CONTENDER for 2024: I’ve been testing and utilizing the KUMIO 2.2-Quart Ice Cream Maker with Compressor side-by-side with my Breville for nearly a 12 months now. This one was an incredible discover (unknown model to me) final 12 months and it’s had stable use with zero complaints.
I do dislike the churning paddle, nobody else has one nearly as good because the Breville, however that’s a small trouble for a bigger machine (2.2 quarts) at almost half the value of the Breville (1.5 quarts). It’s my go-to machine anytime I think the batch can be bigger than common.
That is now my suggestion, each for the bigger measurement and the outcomes I’ve seen up to now. That stated, the Cuisinart is the extra well-known model, they usually’re each stable selections.
Nonetheless, if you wish to splurge and plan to make ice cream greater than as soon as a month, I’m all the time going to like my Breville finest. So, there’s that.
Electrical Ice Cream Maker – frozen bowl, no ice required
The Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker (the Cuisinart ICE-30BC Pure Indulgence 2-Quart – $80 ) is a extremely popular choice for making ice cream at dwelling. That is in all probability essentially the most generally used ice cream maker as we speak.
The original Cuisinart machine was the primary ice cream maker I purchased about 8 years in the past (the Cuisinart ICE-21 1.5-Quart – $69) and I used it endlessly. The mannequin pictured beneath is the upgraded mannequin and makes a bigger batch, however in reality? I don’t prefer it as a lot as my older machine.
For those who’re searching for a dependable electrical ice cream maker below $75, you don’t personal a KitchenAid mixer already and don’t need to mess with salt and ice, the unique Cuisinart ICE-21 is your finest guess for cash spent. That stated, please learn via the entire evaluate as that is my least favourite of all of the machines I examined.
There are a number of downsides to this machine. The bowl should be frozen stable earlier than churning a batch of ice cream. You’re restricted to a single batch of ice cream and might want to refreeze the bowl for 8-12 hours till frozen stable earlier than churning a brand new batch of ice cream.
Regardless of its reputation, this machine produces the least uniform consistency of all of the ice cream makers right here. The freezing isn’t all the time constant and even, as a result of liquid usually freezes to the perimeters of the bowl as pictured beneath.
This makes it tough to get every thing out of the bowl. And should you do get every thing out of the bowl, there can be a number of bizarre “buttery” chunks or slivers within the ice cream.
The Cuisinart machine delivers selfmade ice cream and it’s scrumptious. However, given what number of different choices can be found, this stays my least favourite machine on the listing.
The Cuisinart was the primary electrical ice cream maker I purchased years in the past and I used it endlessly the primary summer season I used to be creating recipes for this web site. So, it does work and it makes nice ice cream.
I gave that unique machine to a pal years in the past, however picked one other one up final week with the intention to do the entire facet by facet comparisons for this text. (And gave the brand new one away as quickly as I used to be achieved with the testing.)
Stand Mixer Attachment Ice Cream Maker – frozen bowl, no ice required
If in case you have a KitchenAid and don’t need to add one other equipment to your kitchen, the KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment at $69 is a terrific ice cream making choice for you.
In a lot the identical means that the Cuisinart works, the bowl is frozen earlier than ice cream may be churned. As soon as frozen, it attaches to the stand mixer and is ready to churn 2-quarts of ice cream.
If you have already got a KitchenAid mixer, it is a much better choice than the Cuisinart, palms down. I examined the 2 machines facet by facet and I’ll inform you proper now that the Cuisinart can’t contact the creaminess and constant texture of the KitchenAid.
If in case you have loads of freezer area, it is a nice choice and produces dependable soft-serve outcomes. For scoopable ice cream, simply pop the completed ice cream into an hermetic container within the freezer till agency.
Electrical Ice Cream Maker – simply add ice and salt
The Hamilton Beach Electric Ice Cream Maker at $49 is the least costly ice cream maker on this listing and it really works surprisingly properly. It is a fundamental, plug it in and churn electrical ice cream machine.
No controls, no changes, simply pour within the ice cream combine, fill the perimeters with ice and salt, and plug it in. (Please don’t buy this machine with out studying this complete evaluate!)
The ice cream comes out of this machine as delicate serve, however nonetheless spoonable. For those who choose firmer ice cream, it may be transferred to an hermetic container and frozen till agency sufficient to scoop.
HOWEVER, the Hamilton Seashore Electrical Ice Cream Maker is loud. As in, loopy unbelievably loud form of loud. I can ignore quite a lot of noise, however this machine truly had me placing in earplugs simply to get via the churning course of.
I additionally examined the Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker at $54. Aspect by facet with the above Hamilton Seashore mannequin, I didn’t discover any noticeable distinction within the churned ice cream. Each batches of ice cream had been fluffy, creamy, just about excellent batches.
One large perk (and critically, it’s a official perk) to the Nostalgia mannequin is the clear lid on the ice cream canister. It is vitally useful to have the ability to see how the ice cream is churning and whether it is nearly achieved!
These electrical machines are 4-quart ice cream makers, so you may make quite a lot of ice cream at one time. The draw back to that is that the machines don’t all the time work as properly for smaller batches. You’ll need to plan on a minimum of doubling most traditional (1.5-quart) selfmade ice cream recipes for finest outcomes.
I like to recommend the Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker over the Hamilton Seashore for the ear safety alone and for that clear lid. However should you don’t thoughts the noise and might probably churn your ice cream close to an outlet on the again porch?
The marginally cheaper one does work each bit in addition to the dearer choice. (Though, Sean was inserting bets on how shortly the screeching grinding motor on a budget one will final. It actually does sound unreal.)
Hand Crank Ice Cream Maker
That is the old style model ice cream maker that many people keep in mind from childhood. I can keep in mind “serving to” my grandpa churn my grandma’s Six Threes Ice Cream of their storage whereas visiting them in the summertime.
There’s a huge distinction within the hand crank ice cream makers in the marketplace and to be blunt right here, you get what you pay for. For those who luck into an quaint hand-crank machine at a yard sale or goodwill, BUY IT if it’s low-cost. Critically. You simply would possibly get fortunate and discover a gem.
Once I first began making ice cream at dwelling, I attempted a pair completely different hand-crank machines (thanks to eBay and the native Goodwill the place I used to be capable of finding them for a steal – ha, now I do know why) and let me simply inform you now that they leaked water and ice all over the place they usually had been rusted as may be. They had been a multitude to make use of and clear up was a ache, however they churned ice cream, so I believed it was cool.
I attempted to search out two hand-crank machines to check facet by facet for this function, however sadly, the critiques of most hand-crank machines in the marketplace now are really horrible. I couldn’t see spending the cash simply to substantiate what so many reviewers have already stated concerning the different hand-crank machines.
That stated, I’ve needed a real workhorse of a hand crank ice cream maker for years and this summer season, I purchased one. The hand crank Immergood Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker at $406 is a DREAM of an ice cream maker.
This hand-crank machine churns 4 instances as a lot ice cream in much less time than the electrical ice cream makers! 6 quarts of soft-serve ice cream in only 20 minutes?! Sure, PLEASE!
Critically, if there’s a heaven for ice cream makers, this ice cream maker has earned a spot there. I’ve little doubt that that is one thing my boys can be utilizing with their households sometime. The standard is unbelievable.
I debated this buy for a very long time (years, truly) earlier than shopping for this ice cream maker and I’ve no regrets. This machine is obtainable in 4-quart, 6-quart, and 8-quart choices and we’ve got already put it to nice use with household visiting this summer season.
I LOVE that we will make ice cream for a crowd so simply and so shortly! And it’s simply plain enjoyable to make use of the hand crank to churn your ice cream. That is additionally a terrific choice for tenting and out of doors actions when electrical energy isn’t obtainable.
And in another nod to the unbelievable high quality right here, the bucket is so thick and properly insulated that it required not fairly ten kilos of ice to fill this large bucket across the ice cream canister. The ice barely melted whereas we had been churning too!
(Compared, the electrical machines that we examined with ice required a 7-lb bag of ice every for his or her batches and it was half water in about 20 minutes for the skinny plastic bucket on the Hamilton Seashore machine.)
My youngest son churned a batch with a pal final week and it was frozen to delicate serve in about 20 minutes. My oldest son and his uncle churned a batch in about the identical time this weekend.
That is the EASIEST hand crank ice cream churn we’ve ever used and I like that it produced a lot unbelievable selfmade ice cream. The quantity of energy required isn’t actually an element, although the youngsters did develop tired of churning each jiffy and traded off.
Now we have the 8-quart Immergood Stainless Metal Ice Cream Maker and it’ll churn a quadruple batch of selfmade ice cream in about 20 minutes. The ensuing ice cream is soft-serve selfmade consistency and may be transferred to an hermetic container and positioned within the freezer for scoopable firmness.
Mushy Serve Ice Cream Maker
The Cuisinart Soft Serve 1.5QT Ice Cream Maker at $124 is the one semi-reliable (per buyer critiques) delicate serve machine in the marketplace and I selected to not take a look at this one. So far as I’m involved, there are WAY too many elements that may have to be washed and handled each time you need to make ice cream.
To be completely sincere, the entire machine appears to be like far too gimmicky. Even for take a look at functions, I couldn’t deliver myself to spend cash on this one. I’d a lot slightly simply churn ice cream to soft-serve consistency in a typical machine after which sprinkle on or stir in no matter toppings we like.
If I’d discovered a non-commercial priced delicate serve machine with stable critiques, I fortunately would’ve examined it (whats up – ice cream lover right here) however after doing intensive analysis, I’m satisfied that there isn’t a soft-serve machine in the marketplace (for below a thousand {dollars}) that’s definitely worth the funding.
Critically, if you’d like delicate serve, purchase any of the machines right here and revel in. In accordance with many of the critiques, I discovered on-line, the lovable dispenser seemingly is not going to even work.
Ice Cream Ball
I’ve tried this methodology up to now and it was an epic fail, so I merely couldn’t deliver myself to purchase one other Ice Cream Ball at $54 simply to check it. Sure, it freezes a bit, but it surely took a stable half-hour of rolling the ball backwards and forwards or shaking it and the top consequence was principally slush.
That is extra a youngsters’ toy than an ice cream maker so far as I’m involved.
Prompt Ice Cream Maker
Have you ever heard of this one? The Chef’n Sweet Spot Instant Ice Cream Maker at $39 was a shock discover whereas I used to be researching this text. With even a slim risk of constructing rolled ice cream at dwelling, how may I resist? (Plus, it was half off on sale when I discovered it.)
Because it seems, it doesn’t actually kind ice cream rolls as you would possibly hope (and in truth, I didn’t count on it to) this was a enjoyable little choice for making a fast ice cream deal with. It does truly work. It freezes a tiny ½ cup serving at a time and we managed to get about 3 servings made earlier than it was too heat to work.
You retain the tray within the freezer and simply pour a serving price of ice cream combine within the tray whenever you’re able to make ice cream. The ice cream begins to freeze instantly and inside about two minutes, you’ll be able to scrape it up in frozen bits for a enjoyable “prompt” bowl of ice cream.
It is a enjoyable means for youths to simply add in their very own toppings and “chop” them into the ice cream too.
In fact, should you’re actually making greater than the tiniest little bit of ice cream? or want ice cream for greater than a few youngsters? This isn’t very sensible in any respect as an ice cream maker.
Whenever you’re achieved, simply rinse the nonetheless chilly tray in heat water, dry it, and re-freeze for subsequent time. Whereas it’s a neat trick to have the ability to make ice cream this fashion, it’s actually extra toy than device.
Nonetheless, should you luck into discovering it on sale, it’s neat to have within the freezer. However for the usual full listed value? This one is a stable nope from me.
Ice Cream In A Bag
Do you know you may make ice cream with simply a few zip-close freezer luggage? Sure, it’s doable. Is it the identical? In my expertise, probably not, however after a while within the freezer it does agency up a bit. No complaints right here although. I like ice cream in just about any kind in any respect, even slushy.
It’s form of enjoyable for a crowd of youngsters although and we’ve achieved this (or tried this) up to now whereas tenting. Need to strive it your self?
How To Make Ice Cream In A Bag
- Pour ½ cup of any ice cream recipe combination right into a quart-size freezer-safe zip-close bag. Seal tightly, eradicating as a lot air as attainable.
- Put a scoop of ice, 3 tablespoons ice cream rock salt, and the bag containing the milk-cream combination right into a gallon-size resealable plastic bag; seal tightly.
- Rock the bag backwards and forwards – there’s no have to shake the bag arduous – till the combination thickens into soft-serve ice cream, about 10 minutes.
Two issues to notice about this “recipe” – it actually solely works properly with the listed ½ cup of ice cream combine, and that does make a reasonably small portion.
Please be aware, should you add extra of the ice cream combine to the bag with the intention to have a bigger serving of ice cream, it might not freeze. This methodology isn’t simply adjusted, because it’s all concerning the science of constructing it freeze.
Compressor Ice Cream Makers
Till a few years in the past, the Breville Smart Scoop Ice Cream Maker was the dreamiest ice cream maker I’ve ever used.
I’ve been identified to name this equipment “my beloved” and it nonetheless holds true that if I may solely have one of many two, I’d eliminate my KitchenAid mixer with the intention to have this machine in my dwelling ceaselessly. Sure, it’s that tremendous.
One of these ice cream maker makes use of the identical compressor expertise used for fridges and freezers for quick cooling. They don’t want any pre-frozen substances or elements.
The Breville machine not solely has a self-refrigerating compressor that brings the substances to a below-freezing temperature, but it surely additionally has a keep-cool setting that lasts as much as an hour. Along with this, there are 12 hardness settings (with pre-sets for sorbet, frozen yogurt, gelato, and ice cream).
The machine routinely senses the hardness of the combination based mostly in your choice and retains it prepared till it’s time to serve.
As one of many pricier ice cream makers in the marketplace, it is a machine for people who find themselves severe about making ice cream. (Be aware the 70+ ice cream recipes on this web site for proof of the place I fall in that class.)
For those who’re searching for the last word in ice cream making choices at dwelling, that is the machine you need in your wishlist.
The Cuisinart Compressor Ice Cream Maker at $261 continues to be extremely standard and it solidly competes with the Breville. And the KUMIO 2.2-Quart Ice Cream Maker with Compressor is one other stable selection at $229 ($279 with a $50 coupon).
Variations between these machines and the Breville? The Cuisinart and the Kumio don’t have a pre-cool characteristic, so in case you have hotter ice cream (i.e. cooked ice cream) you’ll want to sit back it within the fridge earlier than churning.
The Cuisinart has a ten-minute preserve cool characteristic whereas the Breville will preserve your ice cream cool for over an hour. The Kumio has a 30 minute preserve cool characteristic.
(I’ve by no means used that characteristic deliberately – simply as soon as once I forgot I used to be making ice cream and it saved the batch.) Neither of these options alone can be a dealbreaker for me.
Which Compressor Type Ice Cream Maker Is Greatest?
The Cuisinart and the Kumio machines are stable. So far as I’m involved, Cuisinart redeems their ice cream making cred with this machine. It churns ice cream sooner and is a really shut match to the creaminess of the Breville.
Whereas the ice cream made within the Breville IS a teeny bit creamier, I’m not satisfied it’s price the additional price for many functions.
My suggestion for the house prepare dinner is for the Cuisinart or the Kumio. (I’ll depart that selection as much as you, as one has extra identify recognition and the opposite has a bigger quantity.) If you wish to splurge and plan to make ice cream greater than as soon as a month, I’m all the time going to like my Breville finest.
How To Make Ice Cream
First time making ice cream? I like to recommend beginning with the best and easiest homemade ice cream recipe. It’s endlessly adaptable and it lends itself properly to just about any mix-in choices.
Strive including in chopped up blondies or brownies, chocolate chip cookies or oatmeal cookies (sure, add the raisins – the oatmeal raisin ice cream mixture is sooooo good!), chocolate sauce or caramel sauce swirls.
These are my favorite inexpensive containers for storing ice cream. They’re excellent for gifting (who doesn’t love selfmade ice cream?) storage, re-using, and so on. I write the flavors on the lids with a sharpie and it washes off with dish cleaning soap.
I’ve extra ice cream scoops than I can preserve observe of at this level and I positively play favorites. This ice cream scoop does the most effective job ever of slicing via agency ice cream and nonetheless delivers a reasonably scoop. It will get bonus factors for being one of many least costly scoops I personal as properly.
The most well-liked query I get is whether or not it’s attainable to make ice cream with out a machine. The reply is YES. You can also make ice cream with out a machine. Find the full directions here!
{initially printed 7/24/19 – up to date yearly to replicate present pricing and supply extra evaluate info for these machines, final up to date 5/10/24}
